We had been status through a big white board in one of the crucial jail’s tutorial spaces, debriefing how our learn about on hope had long past when the person slipped into the room with out a sound. Like the opposite contributors he used to be over 60, and serving a existence sentence. He had gray hair, and used to be very tall and narrow.
He slowly picked up a chair sooner than slamming it down. I invited him to sign up for us, however he stayed nonetheless whilst the others watched. Then he dragged the chair around the ground with a piercing scrape. I may pay attention my very own pulse.
As I started to talk I spotted he used to be crying. In the beginning, it gave the impression of a whisper of sobs, however then it were given louder. He rose hastily, and got here up as regards to me. I wrote in my fieldwork notes from that day:
My center is racing. He asks, towering over me: ‘How dare you ask us about hope.’ The alarm blares. Guards escort him out. The others take a seat in surprised silence, eyes locked on us, looking forward to a response.
Within the months that adopted, I might meet many different males for whom hope used to be no longer essentially a lifeline as is so frequently assumed, however a burden that they needed to raise, every now and then painfully.
The Insights phase is dedicated to fine quality longform journalism. Our editors paintings with lecturers from many various backgrounds who’re tackling a variety of societal and clinical demanding situations.
Hope isn’t a comfortable phrase in jail. It shapes how folks take care of their sentence and it determines whether or not – and the way – they interact with body of workers and different prisoners. It shapes whether or not they decide to vocational and academic actions, and it sustains connections with folks at the outdoor.
For older life-sentenced prisoners particularly, hope turns into interlinked with sped up aging, with bullying from more youthful prisoners, and with the worry of unencumber into an unknown international.
Some folks would possibly suppose those males don’t deserve hope. However the puts that extinguish it don’t produce more secure prisons. As a substitute, they produce people who find themselves broken, remoted, and no more in a position to reintegrating into society.
The hope undertaking
My undertaking (On the lookout for Hope: the case of aged life-sentenced prisoners) started in August 2022. We had been investigating how the “right to hope” – as outlined through Pass judgement on Ann Energy-Forde in her concurring opinion to the Eu Court docket of Human Rights judgment Vinter and others v the United Kingdom (2013)– interprets at the back of jail partitions for older folks serving existence sentences, lots of whom face narrow possibilities of unencumber because of their complex age and the duration in their jail sentence.
The analysis used to be performed throughout 3 English prisons over one year on my own and analysis affiliate, Helen Gair, with a small group of analysis assistants. We carried out fieldwork in a Class A jail (reserved for folks presenting the perfect ranges of possibility), a Class C (mid-security degree jail, incessantly geared toward coaching and resettlement), and a Class D (open jail or the ultimate level sooner than unencumber).
Each and every facility had its personal scent and sound. The spatial format and day by day rhythm numerous too. For example, the excessive safety website used to be an previous crimson brick Victorian development, and the wings had been organized in a part panopticon (round) design. Outdoor the principle block, guard canine had been walked on a strip of inexperienced that ran alongside a ten-metre-high wall. Within it used to be loud; lockdowns had been widespread, and it smelled of sweat and mold.
What’s hope?
shutterstock/CeltStudio
Within the open jail, the scent of hashish drifted throughout the grounds. Males greeted us in gray tracksuits, incessantly sporting disposable cups of tea. There have been geese and a pond and a RAF aircraft on show.
Within the Class C jail, we incessantly were given misplaced. The alphabetical alignment of structures made little sense to us. We had our personal set of keys which intended lets transfer round independently. Alternatively, rusty locks slowed us down incessantly, and each gate and door needed to be opened and closed at the back of us.
Males elderly 50 and above and serving existence sentences had been invited to take part. We amassed diaries, finished ethnographic jail observations, and ran one-to-one interviews with each and every player.
Moreover, interviews had been carried out with jail body of workers, each running in frontline and office-based roles, to get a way of ways those that paintings closest to aging life-sentenced prisoners perceived hope and whether or not jail practices preserved or restrained it. Total, we would have liked to learn how hope used to be skilled through prisoners and the way it used to be treated as a jail observe.
Idealised hope v jail fact
Within the 2010s, a case used to be introduced sooner than the Eu Court docket of Human Rights through Jeremy Bamber, Douglas Vinter and Peter Moor. That they had each and every been convicted of homicide in the United Kingdom and been given whole-life orders – essentially the most critical type of existence sentence.
Which means through legislation, they had been sentenced to spend the remainder of their lives in jail without a minimal time period set for parole or unencumber. Just a small share of folks get such critical sentences: Myra Hindley and the Yorkshire Ripper Peter Sutcliffe being two examples.
On July 9, 2013, the human rights courtroom dominated that whole-life orders which don’t come with any prospect of unencumber or assessment would quantity to inhuman or degrading remedy, opposite to Article 3 of the Eu Conference on Human Rights. The perception of a “right to hope” used to be first discussed through Pass judgement on Ann Energy-Forde’s concurring judgment:
… Even those that devote essentially the most abhorrent and egregious of acts … nonetheless retain their very important humanity and raise inside themselves the capability to modify. Lengthy and deserved despite the fact that their jail sentences could also be, they maintain the correct to pray that, one day, they’ll have atoned for the wrongs which they have got dedicated. They ought to not be disadvantaged totally of such hope. To disclaim them the revel in of hope could be to disclaim a elementary facet in their humanity and to do this could be degrading.
The correct to pray is thus vested in a chance of unencumber and assessment. What this implies is that there should be a practical risk that any prisoner sentenced to existence imprisonment be thought to be, in the future in time, for unencumber or that the justification for his or her endured detention must be reviewed.
However how does the correct to pray account for the truth of aging in jail?
The speedy and world “greying” of the jail inhabitants certainly complicates the human rights jurisprudencial working out of a proper to pray. As of March 2025, there have been 87,919 folks in jail in England and Wales, with just about one in 5 (18%) elderly 50 or older, in keeping with the Ministry of Justice.
Compounding issues, life-sentenced prisoners now make up round 10% of the sentenced inhabitants, and this workforce is aging abruptly. Nearly a 3rd of “lifers” are over 50. In consequence, previous, life-sentenced prisoners are the fastest-growing subgroup within the gadget.
This phenomenon blended with the present overcrowding disaster produces a variety of managerial and moral demanding situations: mattress areas are tied up for many years, healthcare and social care calls for are on a steep upward push, and the pressures on ill-equipped jail body of workers build up.
The parable of jail unencumber
One essential discovering from our undertaking is that parole and the potential for unencumber all through a prisoner’s existence span turns into reasonably of a delusion for the ones serving existence sentences at a sophisticated age. Normally, life-sentenced prisoners are given a minimal tariff, which is a length when they aren’t eligible for parole. This criminal idea does no longer account for age then again. Dean, 62 , used to be a life-sentenced prisoner on the Class A jail who had served six years. He advised us how unrealistic parole felt in gentle of his age:
I can be 80 years previous sooner than my first parole listening to and in all honesty I don’t know if I can achieve that milestone. Even supposing my well being is affordable, I’m on a wide variety of drugs to stay me going however incarceration has some way of dragging you down so I’m really not constructive.
Trevor used to be 73 after we interviewed him within the Class C jail and were inside of for 27 years. He used to be sat in a wheelchair and had an elastic band wrapped round his center finger and thumb. He defined to us that it helped him cling a pen.
He described years of postponed parole hearings, clinical delays, and transfers to decrease safety prisons being denied as a result of his well being wishes may no longer be met in open jail prerequisites. He requested us merely:
In case you had been in my scenario would you reside in hope or would you surrender your self in your long term?
The revel in of not believing in unencumber is supported through reliable information that displays that few prisoners sentenced to existence get launched all through their lifetime.
One in 5 lifers at the moment are past their tariff, incessantly through a number of years with age-related limitations to parole contributing to extended incarceration. What we spotted all through fieldwork used to be that older prisoners incessantly struggled to get right of entry to or entire permitted programmes on account of mobility problems and cognitive impairment, but additionally because of managerial prioritisation of more youthful prisoners or the ones convicted of shorter sentences.
Emerging deaths in England and Wales amongst older prisoners additional underscores the illusory prospect of unencumber.
Just about 9 in ten of the 192 deaths from herbal reasons within the 12 months 2025 concerned older prisoners and the choice of folks in jail requiring palliative care continues to develop.
From 2016 to 2020, hospitals recorded 190 admissions of older male prisoners with a palliative care prognosis. In more or less 40% of the ones instances, most cancers used to be the principle situation on access. The charity, Inquest, reported in 2020 that most of the deaths in jail had been neither inevitable nor unforeseeable, pointing as an alternative to systemic failings in healthcare provision, communique, emergency intervention, and drugs control.
Within, searching out.
shutterstock/fran_kie
Construction in this, educational students Philippa Tomczak and Ròisìn Mulgrew argued that classifying deaths in custody as “natural” difficult to understand the techniques wherein jail environments give a contribution to deaths that would possibly another way had been have shyed away from.
Moreover, analysis has again and again related self-harm and suicide patterns to stories of hopelessness and social isolation. The contributors in our learn about in a similar way tied the removing of hope to suicides, mentioning examples that they had witnessed in jail.
In his jail diary, a player with thick oblong glasses known as Ian, 65, who had served 33 years of his existence sentence and used to be now held in a Class C jail, wrote:
With the absent (sic) of hope you might have depression. I’ve identified prisoners who’ve dedicated suicide, that they had no hope or expectancies most effective distress and depression.
So there seems to be a contradiction between the criminal risk of unencumber and its sensible improbability within the context of previous and aging, life-sentenced prisoners.
The concern of unencumber
Past the sensible improbability of unencumber, many contributors described how a lot they feared the sector they’d hypothetically re-enter in the future. A number of contributors of their 60s and 70s mirrored on how they not recognised the sector outdoor.
For them, the time spent in jail blended with their bodily and cognitive decline has institutionalised them. They felt they may no longer fare on my own outdoor jail regulations and environments. One guy named Roy, who had spent many years in quite a lot of Class A prisons wrote in his diary:
I don’t have any hope of, or actual need to go away jail, the place I’m now totally institutionalised, I don’t have any duties as opposed to abiding through jail regulations, and few bills.
Any other frail-looking guy named Russell, 68, described in his diary (which he finished from his Class C cellular) how the very concept of a long term had develop into hole: “It’s difficult really because like I say, I haven’t got any hope of getting out of prison as far as I’m concerned. That is it. I’m in prison and that’s as far as it will go.”
Sensible issues akin to technological advances and housing additionally made the very considered unencumber overwhelming. Gary, 63, who had served 24 years, wrote poignantly about his fears of unencumber, announcing: “Release frightens me because of the label that has been firmly given to me and that brings its own problems. Where will I live? How will I live?”
A 73-year-old player named Kevin, who used to be transferred all through the undertaking from a Class C to an open jail, spoke about how, after 21 years in jail, issues can have modified an excessive amount of at the outdoor for him to maintain. As he stood at the doorstep of freedom, he frightened about getting his head round new generation and gaining access to easy such things as his pension. He stated: “Technology has moved on at a phenomenal pace, seems very scary to me … I should stay here in prison where everything is regulated and structured rather than going out to something that is quite alien to me.”
Those emotions are exacerbated through the erosion of social networks, the demise of friends and family, and the disappearance of any significant horizon. Social isolation implies that the sector they’d be reintegrating into has develop into alien and they are going to must navigate it most commonly on my own. Kevin added:
Those that I used to name buddies not wish to know me or have died. Something needless to say that I will be able to [say] is right, you no doubt in finding out who your true buddies are … while you come to jail and particularly for those who come to jail for a very long time.
This feeling of destroyed horizons, the place unencumber holds no promise and the outdoor international has develop into much more terrifying than the cellular, has been dramatised in pop culture.
In The Shawshank Redemption (1994) the nature Brooks, launched after 50 years inside of, unearths himself not able to deal with the tempo and impersonality of the trendy international. His suicide turns into a haunting metaphor for the crushing impact of institutionalisation that hollows out the self and the potential for significant social reintegration.
When hoping turns into damaging
Different prisoners we spoke to reputedly determined it used to be extra recommended for them to surrender on hope altogether. Some – like Barry -– questioned if giving up on hope of unencumber could be much less torturous.
Barry used to be 65 after we spoke to him and has spent over 4 many years in jail on a existence sentence. He’s tall and narrow. When he walked in, we spotted he had a limp and used a cane. The primary time we met, he sat together with his arms clasped, talking in a measured voice that now and again broke into amusing, no longer from humour however extra from what I felt like used to be exhaustion. Despite the fact that parole is technically to be had to him, he has come to look the pursuit of unencumber no longer as hopeful however as damaging.
Over years of disappointments, Barry questioned if dwelling without a hope could be much less painful and felt it had develop into “pointless” to pray. He wrote in his diary:
Hope is after I need one thing to occur or one thing to be true … I incessantly ask myself would it not be kinder to reside without a hope and simply reside with a ‘wait and see’ roughly perspective.
Certainly, each parole listening to postponed, each dashed expectation had eroded the worth of hoping. In the long run, giving up on hope is captured as one thing that at last preserves psychological well being. As Barry added:
An empty case of hope is wholesome, I say that on account of the volume of guys I’ve observed develop into unwell; sadness turns into depression, turns into melancholy, turns into psychological unwell well being … then while you prevent hoping, you begin to get well and also you not really feel hopeless, as you don’t seem to be hoping for the rest. So hope is a paradox, it may well disappoint or make you are feeling there’s a actual risk of items to return.
He recalled studying about an American lady sentenced to existence with out parole who had begged for the demise penalty as an alternative. Her rationalization (“I don’t just want to be alive, I want to be able to live”) resonated with him so powerfully that he stated it, “almost knocked me off my chair”. He recognised in her plea the similar merciless paradox he confronted: that to lengthen his lifestyles in hopeless prerequisites used to be no existence in any respect. His conclusion used to be irrevocable:
I perceive greater than maximum the desire for hope, however all of the years that I’ve been in jail and all of the hopes I’ve had destroyed, I see hope as an enemy.
However then Barry similarly admitted that he nonetheless was hoping, it doesn’t matter what. His hope used to be like a human herbal reflex, over which he had no keep an eye on, it simply took place. He stated: “We all hope … I hope I’ll get out on my next parole.”
What then, is hope in jail? Is it merciless and torturous or is it a human characteristic that brings aid and pressure?
Recalibrating hope
We discovered hope intended various things to other folks. It isn’t near to unencumber. Some wanted detailed plans, others centered at the day after day. On occasion hope shifted against modest targets which might be tied to imagined puts outdoor jail: a quiet retirement, an opportunity to review, to lawn.
Terry used to be 65 and had served 38 years in class A jail. He advised us that every one he was hoping for used to be “a quiet life in retirement”, whilst Russell, who used to be about the similar age however had served over 12 years and used to be in a Class C when he wrote his diary, stated that he was hoping to, “… someday be released and to live the remaining years I have left in a small bungalow with a small garden in a village miles away from my old area of England. Have a pet cat.”
Inexperienced shoots: can hope get well from existence in jail?
shutterstock/GetmanecInna
Others solid their hopes in additional detailed and urban plans about what the long run would appear to be. Carl, 60, who loved cooking and figuring out, for instance, stated he was hoping to transport in together with his daughter and grandchildren for some time in a space the place his ambition is to construct his personal space. He added: “I designed and roughly costed the development plan that helped to reinforce the hope that these plans were achievable.”
Within the second
However different contributors recalibrated hope to extra speedy aspirations set within the provide, and in daily encounters.
Barry stated: “My hope is that I continue to live in the moment … You know, cause right now I’m in this office with you two guys, it’s calm. It’s nice. It’s peaceful. It’s a nice moment. But I’m not gonna think about what it’s gonna be like at 4pm because I might walk out that door and straight into a prison riot.”
Russell agreed, including: “Looking for the future, I just go from one day to the next. It’s no good planning too far ahead.”
This shift of hope raises questions on how prisons form or even restrict the techniques folks can get right of entry to and believe their futures.
Any other player, Craig, who used to be 66 and had most effective served simply over 5 years within the Class A jail after we met him wrote: “… you personalise hope to suit the circumstances.”
For the establishment and the ones running in jail, those attitudes against hope might be perceived as a success as a result of prisoners sentenced to the longest sentences demonstrated a dedication to reside a crime-free existence, set within the provide second, desirous about small menial issues that won’t carry any possibility for control.
But if hope turns into so short-termist and bland, we’re ready to seize a shift within the very common sense of imprisonment – one that is much less about nourishing transformation geared toward resocialisation, and extra in regards to the life-long containment of decaying and death our bodies.
Hope issues
This text opened with a person telling my colleagues and I: “How dare you ask us about hope?” That second has echoed all the way through this learn about, each as an outburst that displays how jail analysis may also be fraught with complexity however too can propel additional and deeper mirrored image on humanitarian beliefs akin to hope.
When folks in jail talk of the cruelty and fallacy of hope, you start to marvel how a lot attractiveness and promise hope in reality holds in areas of excessive keep an eye on and constraint.
When transposed to prisons, hope not appears to be connected to an open horizon, evocative of lightness and liberty discovered anew. As a substitute, it represents dissociation from the outdoor international, and the reason for frustration, distrust and a way of abandonment.
Hope in jail exposes a disconnect between summary criminal humanitarian beliefs and the empirical realities of aging whilst incarcerated for lengthy sessions of time. And this declare may most probably be prolonged to different settings of heightened legislation and tight tracking, akin to care properties, immigration detention centres, and even early life justice amenities.
The verdict to go away from hope’s standard, possibly rather romanticised that means, and to recalibrate it against actual, day by day prerequisites may however illustrate new techniques for the way older life-sentenced prisoners (and others below constraint) regain company and stay going.
In the long run, hope issues – no longer just for the folk I met and interviewed – but additionally for broader society.
Imprisonment marked through hopelessness is related to deteriorating psychological and bodily well being, expanding power on jail healthcare and, upon unencumber, on group well being and social care products and services.
That is exacerbated for older prisoners launched after many years inside of. Hope isn’t a sentimental indulgence, however a situation that shapes whether or not imprisonment prepares folks to reside safely past jail or releases them with profound unmet wishes. Regimes that erode hope possibility simply displacing, moderately than resolving, social damage.
For you: extra from our Insights collection:
